Whitebeam tree

Advice required

Jump to Page: 1
The AntiTog

Send a message to this user
Posts: 2554
Posted At: 30/06/2009 18:28:59

I have a whitebeam tree growing in my front garden, and it is getting quite big.. I like trees, and this one keeps the house cool, and blocks nosey passers by as well as sunlight. Every year I prune off a few small branches which are overhanging the path, and every year it just gets bigger.It's in the centre of the front lawn, and some of the mid-height branches are almost brushing the house, while others are hanging over my neighbour's fence. She is concerned that the roots might interfere with her fence, which prompted me to wonder if they might affect the house. I have this vague notion that tree roots extend beyond the canopy of the tree. Do I need to worry,and if so what can I do about it (and when)?
Paul Sherville

Send a message to this user
Posts: 2833
Posted At: 30/06/2009 20:46:16

As a general idea, many believe that a tree's roots roughly match the canopy, so, if the canopy is overhanging your neighbour's fence, then the roots may well also be in the vicinity too. With regard to possible action, my view on this is very much along the lines of "if it ain't broke - don't fix it".
A lot depends upon soil type and the proximity of other plants. If you have never had problems with soil movements, subsidence / heave, then there shouldn't be an issue. Prune off the bits of the canopy that overhang the fence, and, if you don't like the comforting sounds of the ends of the branches touching the windows on a cold stormy autumnal evening then just cut off the bits closest to the house as well.
If it were mine, I'd leave well alone and enjoy the majestic beauty of a magnificent tree.

Paul
The AntiTog

Send a message to this user
Posts: 2554
Posted At: 01/07/2009 13:50:32

Quoting Paul Sherville (30/06/2009 @ 20:46:16):
As a general idea, many believe that a tree's roots roughly match the canopy, so, if the canopy is overhanging your neighbour's fence, then the roots may well also be in the vicinity too. With regard to possible action, my view on this is very much along the lines of "if it ain't broke - don't fix it".
A lot depends upon soil type and the proximity of other plants. If you have never had problems with soil movements, subsidence / heave, then there shouldn't be an issue. Prune off the bits of the canopy that overhang the fence, and, if you don't like the comforting sounds of the ends of the branches touching the windows on a cold stormy autumnal evening then just cut off the bits closest to the house as well.
If it were mine, I'd leave well alone and enjoy the majestic beauty of a magnificent tree.

Paul

After some consideration, I think it's the depth of the roots that's the issue. Since Googling, I've read, rather alarmingly, that the horizontal spread of the roots is the same as the height of the tree. I haven't had problems with subsidence, etc. yet, but waiting until the problem starts is probably leaving things a bit late. It is definitely too wide for the garden, and rather than me hacking off bits as they smack me in the face, it needs addressing by somebody who knows how to prune it whilst maintaining some shape. I'm inclined to ask a tree surgeon for advice and an estimate. Hopefully, the roots are deep enough not to be problematic. The only other plant in the vicinity is the lawn (complete with various weeds, and an annual crop of bluebells.)
Jump to Page: 1
Please note: contents of discussions and comments submitted to the Zone forums are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of Saga or the Acromas Group, who cannot take responsibility for the views expressed by participants on the site.
Privacy Policy Terms and Conditions © COPYRIGHT SAGA